Michael Johns is safe
David Archuleta is safe.
Carly Smithson is safe.
David Cook is safe.
Ramiele Malubay (I know that spelling is off) is bottom 3
Kristy Lee Cook is bottom three.
Syesha Mercado is safe.
Brooke and Jason Castro ... last two to the stage. Jason is safe, Brook bottom three with Ramiele and Kristy.
Brooke is safe.
Ramiele is going home.
9 comments:
What is this Song abotu Jesue and who are those other two guys playing with this kid. Sorry for if this is a lame question. I have not been able to follow AI this season much. Saw only a few shows.
Those were the Clark Brothers. They won The Next Great American Band, a Fox show I reviewed for TVS last fall.
I think either ramiele or kristy should go home
Thanks Jackie for the info. I do not watch the result shows for AI or DWTS, so for AI I am thankful you report results.
I forgot to look at DWTS result until about 4p this aft. Ha Ha, guess I am not too excited about this year's group yet.
I wasn't surprised that Ramiele got the boot,but was shocked to see Brooke in the bottom three. It's a good thing the little teenies are voting for Jason,cause his behind should have been in that group.Ramiele is just still too young and inexperienced for this gig.She complained that she doesn't "know" country music and all other kind of things. Have you ever watched AI before,girl?
And this week,I loved,loved,loved David Cook's rendition of Dolly's "Little Sparrow". I bet Simon hated Dolly's performance,too. He made cracks about the whole Jesus references and all when the kids sang. I also thought the Clark Brothers were a leetle bit over the top tonight too. I would have liked for them to have sung something else. They were almost manic to the point where the song suffered.
I cannot believe Brooke was in the Bottom 3. No way did she deserve that. Even if this week wasn't a great performance, she had much better peformances all along than many of the other contestants. It's just too bad they used 9 to 5 for the group sing, because Brooke sounded great on that song when she led off. Actually, Kristy Lee did a nice job with 9 to 5 as well.
Top 3: Brooke, Carly & David C.
At least that's what I'm hoping for :-)
Oh yeah, and considering I loved the Clark Bros on the Band Show, they were a bit disappointing last night. They were much better on their show and for people who didn't watch it, the Idol performance didn't really showcase their talent.
I like David A., Brook and Carly for the final 3. Brook needs more of a fan base to keep her there, which is a shame, because I love her voice.
I normally like Simon's perspective on the singers, but he is not a good judge if he can't put his personal feelings aside re the country western songs, and judge according to the voices.
On the plus side regarding Brooke, although she probably won't win, she's gotten a lot of exposure and will probably get a record contract out of this regardless. Which is fine by me, cause look how good it worked out for Daughtry not winning. I could see the same outcome for Brooke. I'd certainly buy her CD, which is more than I can say for most of the AI winners (with the exception of Carrie Underwood).
Post a Comment